Lawyer Autonomy and You're Not the Boss of Me-ism
/Lawyers tend to prefer working alone. Many don’t enjoy being managed. That’s fine. To each his own. The desire for independence is neither good nor bad. At times, this trait is valuable and necessary. But when law firm partners choose autonomy over the health of their law firms, they reveal themselves as unqualified to be business owners. The desire for complete autonomy is one of the most insidious and corrosive forces shaping law firm culture. This isn’t new. What’s changed is other partners' appetite to tolerate it.
It’s commonly understood that lawyers are different. Dr. Larry Richard has written extensively about lawyer personalities, and we won’t try to improve upon his work here. Read this. And this. And this. While there are many differences between lawyer personalities and the general public, our focus is on autonomy. Lawyers are in the 89th percentile in preference for autonomy, compared to the 50th percentile for everyone else. What does that mean? According to the Cambridge Dictionary, autonomy is “the ability to make your own decisions without being controlled by anyone else.”
If a lawyer’s desire for autonomy is so strong that he simply will not accept any input or intrusion into his practice focus, client selection, matter staffing decisions, prices, methods and tools of practice, business operations, or communication style, there’s a perfect answer: hang a shingle and launch a solo law firm. Over time, hire more people and dictate how things will run. It’s that simple.
From “Herding Cats: The Lawyer Personality Revealed,” © Dr. Larry Richard, LawyerBrain℠
Not surprisingly, roughly 63% of the 1.3 million active private-practice lawyers in the US are solos or in firms with fewer than 5 lawyers (here). Nearly 87% of private practice lawyers in the UK are solos or in firms with fewer than 5 lawyers (here). And 86% of Australian private practice lawyers are solos or in firms with fewer than 5 lawyers (here). So… problem solved? The remaining private practice lawyers working in larger firms must have accepted the necessity and mutual benefits of centralized governance? Not even close.
Many lawyers are risk-averse relative to the overall population (see Dr. Larry Richard’s work above), so they combine forces specifically to share risk and overhead, so that when one practice is doing well and another is trending downward, earnings are smooth. And when these practices eventually trade places, earnings remain smooth. Lawyers who choose to join forces to mitigate their risk in this way forgo complete autonomy. Their individual success is inextricably linked to the firm’s success. Law firm partners, as owners of the business, have a personal, professional, and fiduciary obligation to act in ways that benefit the organization's greater good. Yet many partners act selfishly, prioritizing the firm's needs far below their personal preferences.
Biglaw culture generally allows partners, particularly those managing key clients or generating significant billables, broad discretion to set their own course. They’re allowed to substitute their own preferences or peccadillos for sound business decisions. An inclusive and flexible culture can accommodate one partner’s quirky affectation for tweed jackets and high-top basketball shoes or another partner’s demand for a Mac instead of a Windows laptop. But law firms struggling to find their way in a changing marketplace can no longer tolerate partners whose demands to be left alone and unmanaged harm the enterprise.
There are obvious ways in which unbridled autonomy can be harmful. There are also numerous non-obvious ways. Let’s explore a few ways partners reveal themselves as individual contributors in disguise.
Hoarding. Some partners like to do the work themselves rather than delegate. This can be harmful in the short run because leverage (a.k.a. delegation to lower-cost juniors) generates profits, and in the long run because charging partner rates while competitors charge associate rates places the firm at a distinct competitive disadvantage. When the partner addresses this by discounting to an associate-level rate, every hour the partner bills dilutes the firm’s profits. A partner who claims to be a perfectionist who can’t trust others to do the work properly has revealed an inability or lack of interest in training or mentoring, which are generally considered critical contributions of a business owner.
Working alone. Owners focus on growing the business for everyone, for today and tomorrow. Individual contributors focus on their personal productivity. Collaboration is a critical driver of growth, whether in delivering legal work or in pursuing business development opportunities. Owners work and hunt in packs. Individual contributors work and hunt alone.
Withholding credit. Owners adopt a bounty perspective: “How many colleagues can I involve to ensure this client engagement or relationship is successful?” Individual contributors adopt a scarcity perspective: ”How can I retain all credit for my personal contribution, even if it means losing some opportunities where I would have to share credit?”
Failure to cross-sell. Owners view clients as the firm’s clients and constantly seek to proactively broaden the scope and depth of client relationships. Individual contributors jealously guard key client relationships, refuse to share contacts or use the firm’s CRM system, and limit opportunities to identify or address unmet client needs outside their personal area of expertise. When key clients are funneled through a single point of contact at the firm, they always have a higher flight risk than clients actively engaging with multiple practices and contacts.
Over-pricing/over-billing. Owners recognize that long-term profitability depends on satisfied clients, and sometimes that means pricing for the long run rather than for immediate profits. Individual contributors bill as much as they can and collect as much as they can, irrespective of client price sensitivity, even at the risk of alienating clients. “That’s next year’s problem” is not a business owner's mindset.
Under-pricing/under-billing. In a price-sensitive market, lowering rates (or slowing the pace of rate increases) can be an appropriate tactic to remain price competitive and fully utilized. But self-serving partners proactively and unnecessarily offer rate discounts in every pitch, write down others’ time on a pre-bill while preserving their own time entries, offer discounts as the solution to every client satisfaction issue, or offer invoice write-offs rather than pursuing the collection of aged receivables. The result is that all partners share in the profit dilution while only the individual partner benefits from increased compensation. Owners seek to earn the highest rewards primarily by boosting the firm’s financial performance.
Resist re-engineering. Owners constantly seek a competitive advantage and embrace a culture of continuous improvement. They ask: “How can we use our deep expertise to deliver higher quality, faster throughput, greater client satisfaction, and improved firm profits?” Individual contributors resolutely stick to their preferred approach, even if it's inconsistent with how others deliver the same work or how clients want the work done, believing their “artistic license” takes precedence over consistency, quality, and competitiveness.
Poor fiscal hygiene. Owners record their time, review pre-bills, issue invoices, and collect fees diligently and in a timely manner. They manage client expectations by proactively using matter budgets and communicating scope changes. Individual contributors submit incomplete and tardy timesheets, provide incomplete and ambiguous task descriptions that invite client review and write-offs, delay pre-bill reviews, and send invoices long after the work is done. When the client inevitably pushes back, they discount heavily, particularly when rewards focus on cash in the door.
Given the wholesale revolution taking place in the legal marketplace, law firm leaders and partner-owners can’t and shouldn’t be required to subsidize the whims of partners who are unable or unwilling to do what’s best for the firm. Those who act selfishly may be excellent individual contributors — quite possibly highly compensated because what they offer has market value. But they have revealed themselves to be unqualified to be owners of the business. Their contributions, while valuable, need to be managed and rewarded appropriately.
Inaction is costly. Selfish partners dilute profits, alienate clients, impair morale, and hold back the firm competitively. Addressing these issues can be thorny, but the payoff is meaningful. The action plan is simple:
Identify what it means to be a partner or shareholder of your law firm. While it may sound “new agey,” this is about establishing a clear code of conduct for the business. It’s critical for the business owners to enumerate the behaviors they expect of each other and how they’ll hold themselves accountable. It’s not enough to post the values on a plaque in the firm’s lobby. It’s important for the owners to live these values every day, from the top down, without exception.
Measure profit and client satisfaction. Profit is obviously a desirable financial objective, but it’s also a decent proxy for long-term client satisfaction. Sustainable profit comes from delivering what clients want, in the way clients want it, at prices the market is willing to pay. The traditional approach of measuring inputs, or units of partner productivity that grow top-line revenue, isn’t enough. Business owners must also measure outcomes, including matter profitability and client satisfaction and retention.
Review and update the partner compensation plan. If partners are presented with a choice between acting in their own self-interest or doing what’s right for the firm, then the incentives are misaligned. It’s the responsibility of the firm’s management, acting on behalf of all shareholders, to align “what’s good for the partner with what’s good for the partnership,” as the saying goes. Astonishingly, in too many law firms, the shareholders whose conduct is furthest from the firm’s values are also the highest-paid. To be fair, many of those implicated aren’t necessarily bad actors, particularly when they engage in conduct that the compensation not only allows but rewards. When the compensation plan, operating agreement, or other governance documents don’t restrict self-serving conduct, management will rarely change behavior through pleading or coercion. Management must minimize self-serving choices by aligning partner rewards with the firm’s strategic priorities.
The legal profession is changing rapidly. However, whatever the future holds, organizational adaptability will always be a competitive advantage. In these uncertain times, leaders must take bold action. Let’s get started.
Tim Corcoran is principal of Corcoran Consulting Group, based in New York with a global client base. He’s a Fellow and past Trustee of the College of Law Practice Management, past President of the international Legal Marketing Association and a member of its Hall of Fame, an American Lawyer Research Fellow, a former Teaching Fellow at the Australian College of Law, a prolific author, and a sought-after keynote speaker at law firm retreats and legal conferences. A former legal technology CEO, Tim focuses on guiding law firm leaders through the profitable disruption of outdated business models. Tim can be reached at Tim@BringInTim.com and +1.609.557.7311.
